NEW on the SCC’s Webpage below
Motions for leave to intervene and oral argument at the hearing of the appeal
These are my thoughts right off the bat – I may revisit them, revise them, take the opposing view, with time, who knows?
See the New Practice Direction here: https://scc-csc.ca/parties/arf-lrf/notices-avis/26-11/
This is important. The Pilot Project is exactly responsive to some organizations’ long-time, repeated lobbying of the Court for a host of these changes to how intervention proceeds in the Supreme Court of Canada | Cour suprême du Canada.
Who Gets to Make Oral Argument – Justifying Why You Should Be Permitted to Address the Court
As an intervener, your client is no longer guaranteed oral argument time, even if granted leave to file a Factum. Instead:
Any intervener seeking leave to intervene who wishes to present oral argument at the hearing of the appeal must make that request in the motion for leave to intervene and indicate how its submissions on oral argument will be useful and will benefit the Court.
The first part, seeking leave to make oral argument, has always been required — what’s new is that you now have to explain why or how oral argument specifically will assist the Court. Inevitably, this means some interveners granted leave to intervene will only be permitted to file a factum. They won’t be addressing the Court directly.
For some people, this will come as a shock. I started appearing in that court sufficiently long ago, in the prehistoric era, that I know it’s been done this way before. Was it really helpful to anyone? I’m not sure. Does it save court time? Maybe. It depends how long the arguments that are allowed, are allowed to go on.
Back then, you were required to appear (in person, ’cause there was no other way) even if you were not granted oral argument. That, frankly, felt a little like adding insult to injury as you were forced to watch your colleagues who’d won the oral argument lottery address the court, often for as long as 15 minutes, if you can imagine that. There’s no suggestion you’d be required to appear now, if you’re not granted oral argument, or is there? I don’t know!
But there’s nothing wrong in principle with the suggestion that not all Facta are created equal and some parties’ arguments would benefit from an oral hearing, where others may not. Perhaps paradoxically, the better your Factum is, the less likely it will require clarification by way of oral submissions. There may be no questions for you at all once it’s been read.
However, one does worry whether the habitual interveners, those juggernauts who appear on every appeal in one or another area of the law and have done so for seemingly ever, like the Criminal Lawyers’ Association (the CLA) or the Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA) may be permitted oral argument more readily than smaller or newer social justice organizations, who may have less of an established history in our apex court, or none at all.
There is at least the potential for preferential treatment based on reputation, rather than the submission, though that’s anxiety smaller potential interveners may have based on exactly zero actual evidence at the minute anyway. But that was of course the beauty of the equal treatment that universal application of the rules of intervention thus far. Sure, occasionally some organizations were denied leave altogether, but this was the exception rather than the rule. We’ll see if even that changes, or just who appears in the Court to address it directly will be affected.
Regardless of all that, what I most acutely lament is the loss of opportunities now for junior counsel to make oral argument in our country’s highest court. If fewer interveners will be heard, fewer juniors will speak there. That’s sad, mainly for me, as I’ve devoted the last number of years to mentoring and coaching dozens of young women criminal defence lawyers very specifically in the art and science of exactly these 5 minutes on their feet – or in their seat as it were. So that is how this is about me.
How Oral Arguments May Be Made – A Choice between In Person or Virtual Attendance
Speaking for myself, I have voiced concerns about allowing even the option of in person or Zoom argument by interveners, because those in person may be more compelling, which is not a consideration if all interveners are appearing virtually. But I realize this view is not shared by many. In general, options and choices are good and likely a positive development here.
However, only one counsel can appear in person for an intervener. The good news is even with that, it sounds like up to four lawyers will still have their name on the Judgment, despite not being permitted to appear, although this is not entirely clear to me based on the following advice in the Notice of the Pilot Project as follows:
Only one counsel will be permitted to attend at the hearing and present oral argument if an intervener chooses to appear in person.
Up to four names of counsel for interveners will be listed in the judgment, including counsel providing written submissions only.
Finally, the most puzzling thing to me at least is the requirement that counsel advise their client of the virtual appearance option for interveners. This is in line with other trends, including a practice rule in some courts to certify that cited text from case law has been verified as accurate. I personally think if we are headed toward providing a lawyer’s undertaking specifically to either do or attest that we have done all the things that our professional conduct rules require of us no matter what, things are gonna get a little weird and overwhelming.
Here is what the SCC now requires of intervener counsel:
Counsel for interveners granted permission to make oral argument who choose to appear in person must advise the Court and are required to file, along with the notice of appearance set out in rule 71(4), an attestation certifying that they have advised their clients that appearing in person is optional and that all types of submissions are given equal consideration.
This kind of additional administrative burden adds to the global cost of intervention, which potentially contributes to a chilling effect against seeking leave to intervene for those tiny, non-profit or utterly unfunded groups whose counsel habitually acts pro bono, with zero additional resources to never mind travel to Ottawa, but even file documents newly designed to confirm basic professional responsibilities.
Edit: Since I wrote this, Canadian Lawyer has published an article with the opinions of many who often appear in the Supreme Court of Canada.